A mental health claim needs to explain the person’s circumstances against the actual policy. This client story shows why the connection between medical evidence and work capacity matters.
By the ClaimRight team · Updated 15 November 2026
Free initial discussion. No obligation to engage us.
Published by ClaimRight · Meet our founder, William Johns
The result: a $450,000 TPD benefit
In this ClaimRight client matter, a $450,000 total and permanent disability (TPD) benefit was approved after medical and psychiatric evidence demonstrated the impact of the person’s mental health condition on their capacity for work.
The value of the claim came from the cover available under the policy. The work involved was making the relevant circumstances and evidence clear. This is an individual result, not an indication of what another person will receive.
A diagnosis is only part of the picture
People often tell us, “My doctor knows I’m unwell. Why is the insurer asking for more?” A diagnosis can explain the condition, but the insurer also needs evidence addressing the definition in the policy.
That may involve how symptoms affect concentration, attendance, interactions, decision-making and the ability to sustain work. Different policies use different tests, including own occupation, any occupation or other definitions.
What mattered in this claim
The case centred on documented psychiatric evidence and the connection between the condition and incapacity for work. A carefully organised claim helps the decision-maker understand the evidence as a whole.
- The relevant history: treatment records and how the condition developed over time.
- The functional impact: what the person could and could not sustain in a work setting.
- The medical opinions: the treating evidence about capacity and prognosis.
- The policy requirements: how that evidence related to the definition being assessed.
The lesson is not that everyone needs the same reports. It is that the right evidence needs to answer the right questions.
Not sure your claim tells the full story?
You do not need to explain everything perfectly. Start with a free discussion about your cover, where things stand and what support may help.
Free initial discussion. No obligation to engage us.
Experienced advocacy, without carrying it alone
When you are managing a mental health condition, repeated forms and requests can add to the strain. ClaimRight helps organise the evidence, explain what is being asked and manage communication with the insurer and fund.
If a report or decision appears to miss important context, we examine the issue and prepare a reasoned response within our agreed scope. Where a matter needs specialist legal advice, we explain that too.
If your claim has stalled or been declined
Keep the insurer’s letter, note any response date and seek help promptly. A request for more information, a “minded to decline” letter and a final decline are different stages. Each needs a response suited to the actual issue.
We can discuss a new claim, a delayed claim or the scope of a second opinion if someone is already assisting you. A review does not guarantee a different decision.
Let’s work out your next step
Call 1300 124 499 or choose a time for a free initial discussion. A family member or support person can make the first enquiry.
Free initial discussion. No obligation to engage us.
Questions people ask
Can mental illness qualify for a TPD claim?
A mental health condition may support a claim if the relevant policy definition and other requirements are met. Diagnosis alone does not determine the outcome. Cover dates, exclusions, work capacity and the medical evidence need to be considered.
Do I need to have tried returning to work?
Requirements vary. An existing work attempt may provide useful evidence, but you should not attempt work, stop treatment or change employment arrangements just to build a claim. Discuss your health and work arrangements with the appropriate professionals.
Would my payment be the same as this client’s?
No comparison can establish your entitlement. The insured amount, policy terms, cover dates and your circumstances determine what may be available. This $450,000 result relates to one individual claim.
General information only. This article does not take your personal circumstances into account and is not personal financial, tax or legal advice. Cover, definitions and evidence requirements vary. Past results do not guarantee future outcomes.
Meet the ClaimRight team · View fees and costs · Get the free TPD guide