An insurer’s decline should be examined against the policy and the evidence. This client matter shows why a close reading can change the direction of a claim.
By the ClaimRight team · Updated 15 November 2026
Free initial discussion. No obligation to engage us.
Published by ClaimRight · Meet our founder, William Johns
The client result
In this ClaimRight matter, an insurer initially declined a claim on the basis of a pre-existing condition. A detailed review of the policy wording and medical timeline led to the decision being reversed and the benefit approved.
The review considered the client’s earlier symptoms, capacity for work when cover began and the later development of disabling symptoms. The evidence was considered against the particular exclusion in that policy.
This was one client’s result. Earlier work capacity does not, by itself, mean a pre-existing condition exclusion cannot apply.
The wording decides what needs to be answered
“Pre-existing condition” sounds straightforward, but policies define it differently. The relevant period, symptoms, advice, treatment and connection to the condition being claimed may all matter.
A useful response addresses the insurer’s actual reason rather than simply repeating that the person is now unable to work. The policy wording and the medical history need to be considered together.
What helped clarify this matter
The review brought together the medical history before and after cover commenced, evidence about work capacity and specialist opinions about when the incapacity developed.
That helped explain the difference between the earlier history and the later disabling condition under the relevant wording. The insurer reassessed the claim and approved the benefit.
Our role is to scrutinise the reasons, identify what needs clarification and present a clear response. We keep the detailed analysis specific to the client and their policy.
Your decline deserves a careful reading
If a pre-existing condition or disclosure issue has been raised, let’s discuss what the letter says, the response date and whether ClaimRight can assist.
Free initial discussion. No obligation to engage us.
Two different issues that are often confused
A policy exclusion
The question is whether a term in the policy excludes the condition or circumstances being claimed.
Information given when cover began
A disclosure or misrepresentation dispute concerns what was asked and answered when cover was applied for or changed. It needs a different analysis.
Do not assume an internet example resolves either issue. Keep the application, policy documents, decision and medical records so the actual position can be reviewed.
What to have ready for the first conversation
- The insurer or super fund’s name and any claim reference.
- The decision letter or request for a response.
- The response date, if one is stated.
- A broad outline of when cover began and when your health affected work.
You do not need to upload medical records to make the initial enquiry. We will explain the documents and authority needed if we can assist. Some matters require specialist legal advice.
You can also complain directly to the insurer or trustee. AFCA explains the special rules for superannuation complaints. Seek timely guidance about the deadline that applies to your situation.
A difficult decision does not have to be faced alone
Call 1300 124 499 or book a free initial discussion. We will explain the support we can offer, its scope and the next step.
Free initial discussion. No obligation to engage us.
Questions people ask
Does having an earlier diagnosis automatically rule out TPD?
Not automatically. Whether an exclusion applies depends on its actual wording, cover dates and the relevant history. Some exclusions may apply even if you were working at the time, so the details need individual review.
Is a pre-existing condition exclusion the same as non-disclosure?
No. An exclusion concerns the cover and policy terms. A non-disclosure or misrepresentation issue concerns information provided when applying for or changing cover. A decision may raise one or both issues, and the response needs to address the actual reasons.
Should I wait before responding to a decline?
Keep the decision and all correspondence, note response dates and seek help promptly. Complaint and review time limits can apply and differ according to the decision and type of complaint.
General information only. This article does not take your personal circumstances into account and is not personal financial, tax or legal advice. Cover, definitions and evidence requirements vary. Past results do not guarantee future outcomes.
Meet the ClaimRight team · View fees and costs · Get the free TPD guide